Keenan Allen, Goodbye or Hello Again?

[foreigner]

Keenan sucked on his rookie season... and his Raider hat spoke volumes... Ladede seems more commited.

Not exactly sucked to be honest...

[richpjr]

I dont think so. Keenan came on strong from the start as a rookie. Ladd is doing decent but nowhere near what Keenan was doing. But natural athletic ability...yes Ladd is more athletic than Keenan ever was.

He did put up solid numbers as the season went on and ended up with 71 catches and 8 TDs. I'm just pointing out that early in the season his numbers were not better than what Ladd has done.

[21&500]

[BayAreaBoltz]

He did put up solid numbers as the season went on and ended up with 71 catches and 8 TDs. I'm just pointing out that early in the season his numbers were not better than what Ladd has done.

Oh, then yup. Agreed.

[21&500]

Week 6:
KA: 5/41 2TDs
LM: 4/43 0TDs

Year:
KA: 15/122 2TDs (missed 2 games)
LM: 19/219 2TDs

Good day for Allen, closing the gap.

Week 7:
KA: bye
LM: 5/46 0TDs

Year:
KA: 15/122 2TDs 2 games missed
LM: 24/265 2TDs 0 games missed

(both players have had their bye week)

[AFboltfan]

Comparing KA to LM at this point accomplishes nothing... KA set franchise rookie records in receptions and yards. LM will be a great WR for us but he is not the next KA...

[richpjr]

Comparing KA to LM at this point accomplishes nothing... KA set franchise rookie records in receptions and yards. LM will be a great WR for us but he is not the next KA...

Way to early to make this claim, IMO.

[Budsman]

Laad looks good. He doesnt look game changing but he’s going to be a very solid option for Herbert.

Allen would have 100% helped us win games this season but obviously isn’t there for the long term rebuild that Harbaugh requires.

[BlazingBolt]

I think I agree we have a player like Keenan Allen we would have won last night. This offense is total trash under Roman. The Cardinals defense is not good and we shit the be against them

[AFboltfan]

Way to early to make this claim, IMO.

What claim? Ladd isn't breaking any rookie records, that's a fact.

[RollingThunder]

Week 7:
KA: bye
LM: 5/46 0TDs

Year:
KA: 15/122 2TDs 2 games missed
LM: 24/265 2TDs 0 games missed

(both players have had their bye week)

Bump for your update.

[richpjr]

Bump for your update.

Here you go:

Week 8:
KA: 2/35 0 TDs
LM: 6/111 2 TDs

Year:
KA: 17/157 2 TDs 2 games missed
LM: 30 376 4 TDs 0 games missed