GM Candidates 2023 Thread

Collapse
X
Collapse
First Prev Next Last
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • ghost
    The Rise of Kellen Moore
    • Jun 2013
    • 5505
    • Send PM

    GM Candidates 2023 Thread

    If you can't hold your horses to talk about the 2023 season (like yours truly here) let's post it here, friends. Black Monday is six weeks away.


    SCOUTING SIDE CANDIDATES

    Mike Borgonzi, Chiefs assistant GM: Originally brought aboard by ex-Kansas City GM Scott Pioli, Borgonzi steadily rose through the organization, then was held over by Andy Reid and John Dorsey. Under Pioli, the Brown alum got experience on the ops side, served as the team’s pro scouting director, and as Brett Veach’s No. 2 has more recently been involved on the college side, too.

    Brandon Brown, Eagles director of player personnel: Part of Howie Roseman’s robust scouting department, Brown’s primary experience is in pro scouting. But he’s done more with the draft over the last year, and has a really interesting background, with a law degree and a job in college football compliance giving him a good ability to see the big picture organizationally.

    Morocco Brown, Colts college scouting director: A decade ago, Brown was seen as riser in the field, having ascended to pro director in Washington, before Ray Farmer hired him in Cleveland to be Farmer’s No. 2. Unfortunately for Brown, Farmer only lasted two years in that job, and Brown had to reset thereafter. Since, he’s reemerged as a vital piece of Chris Ballard’s staff in Indy—and as the lead guy on the college side, giving him experience having directed both a pro and college department.

    Ran Carthon, 49ers director of player personnel: Ryan Cowden, Titans VP of player personnel: Cowden worked under Marty Hurney and Dave Gettleman in Carolina, and now have five years of experience working in GM Jon Robinson’s Patriot-centric scouting system. He’s worked extensively on both the college and pro sides, and interviewed for the Washington GM job last year, with ex-Panthers coach Ron Rivera.

    Glenn Cook, Browns VP of player personnel: Ian Cunningham, Eagles director of player personnel: Ed Dodds, Colts assistant GM: Long seen as one of the NFL’s premier evaluators, Dodds was seen as a secret weapon of Seattle GM John Schneider’s, before Ballard swiped him from the Seahawks upon arriving in Indy. Since then, he’s become Ballard’s right-hand man as the Colts have built one of the NFL’s most talented rosters. Dodds interviewed with the Panthers and Lions last year, and was very high on Robert Saleh’s list of potential GMs had Saleh not landed in a place with a sitting GM.

    Joe Hortiz, Ravens director of player personnel: The Ravens’ longtime college scouting director moved into Eric DeCosta’s old role when DeCosta replaced a retiring Newsome, and still runs the draft while serving in a more comprehensive capacity. Given how Baltimore has continued to be innovative and forward-thinking as an organization, on just about every front, Hortiz should be well-positioned to get his shot soon.

    Brandon Hunt, Steelers pro scouting director: Hunt’s another Steelers personnel man to work through the ranks, and he could be in line to take another step forward if GM Kevin Colbert retires after the draft. He’s worked on both the pro and college side, and the team’s pro department has shined over the last few years, with the team more active in seeking veteran additions (Minkah Fitzpatrick, Joe Haden, etc.).

    Jeff Ireland, Saints assistant GM: Ireland’s draft record since landing in New Orleans has been incredible—since knocking it out of the park in 2016 and ’17 on draft day, the Saints have consistently fielded one of the NFL’s most talented rosters. The ex-Dolphins GM interviewed for the Detroit and Carolina openings last year, and is very well-connected in the sport.

    Will McClay, Cowboys VP of player personnel: The question isn’t whether McClay could land a job, it’s whether he’ll want to go—he’s the top personnel man in the Cowboys’ organization, he’s rooted in Texas and the Jones family loves and takes good care of him. And for good reason—McClay’s helped Dallas consistently field outstanding rosters, and has experience not just in scouting but also coaching and analytics. (There’s a big part of me that believes he’s exactly what the Giants need.)

    Dan Morgan, Panthers assistant GM: Morgan’s name should sound familiar. But the ex-Panthers linebacker isn’t just a former player—he very much paid his dues working his way up in the Seattle pro scouting department during the Legion of Boom years, before going to Buffalo as a key piece of the Bills’ rebuild. He’s been in Carolina since May, helping lead Scott Fitterer’s strong department, which included a couple of guys, in VP Pat Stewart and lead negotiator Samir Suleiman, who were also considered for the GM job in Charlotte.

    Monti Ossenfort, Titans director of player personnel: Ossenfort succeeded Robinson as Patriots college scouting director nearly a decade ago, then followed him to Nashville, and in doing so has diversified his portfolio. He was a finalist for the Panthers’ GM job last year, and his New England–based connection to Giants coach Joe Judge (the two have a good relationship) could put him in contention for the Giants job next month.

    Adam Peters, 49ers assistant GM: Peters was another finalist for the Carolina job last year, and has worked for John Elway in Denver and Bill Belichick in New England. He originally went to Denver with Josh McDaniels in 2009, which could be something to keep in mind should McDaniels land a job somewhere.

    John Spytek, Buccaneers VP of player personnel: Spytek replaced Robinson in Tampa Bay, and has been integral to building the Bucs into champion alongside Jason Licht for the last six years. Before that, he worked on the college scouting side in Denver, winning a Super Bowl there, and started in his career in a loaded personnel department under Andy Reid in Philly.

    Jon-Eric Sullivan, Packers director of player personnel: A newcomer to the list! Sullivan’s name came up a bunch when I called around the last couple of weeks. Brian Gutekunst has Sullivan captaining the personnel department, and his background is very similar to that of the GM—he worked his way to become a Southeast area scout for the Packers, before becoming Green Bay’s college scouting director. Sullivan’s one of a number of young guys to watch in that department (pro director Richmond Williams is another).

    Duke Tobin, Bengals director of player personnel: Tobin is, in many ways, already a GM. Could someone pry him from the Bengals? It doesn’t seem likely, but there’d be reason for interest. Tobin was a hot name a few years back, credited with building Cincinnati’s playoff teams from 2011 to ’15, and he’s since got through a teardown and built the team back up to a point where it sure looks like Cincinnati has a chance to be very good for a while again.

    Adrian Wilson, Cardinals VP of pro scouting: You remember Wilson as the enforcer in the secondary for some excellent Cardinals teams more than a decade ago. But since then? He’s become Arizona GM Steve Keim’s right-hand man, so he brings scouting expertise, and the sort of player credibility John Lynch has, to the table. The Cards’ personnel department—which has other strong names for the future like Quentin Harris and Dru Grigson—has done a very nice job in rebuilding what was a really shaky roster a few years back.

    Eliot Wolf, Patriots scouting consultant: The son of the legendary Ron Wolf is back on the list, and deservedly so. Wolf was runner-up for the Packers’ job in 2018, when Gutekunst was elevated, after being a cornerstone for the Green Bay scouting department for years. He then left for Cleveland, where he was Dorsey’s assistant GM, before those guys were blown out after the ’19 season. And in New England? He’s been invaluable, helping the Patriots change their scouting setup last year, by bringing a strong outside perspective.


    OPERATIONS SIDE CANDIDATES

    Chad Brinker, Packers personnel/football administration executive:Mike Greenberg, Buccaneers VP of football administration: One of the most respected contract negotiators in the sport, Greenberg has become one of Licht’s most trusted confidants—and he more or less frees Licht to be an evaluator because he’s fully capable of running everything else. Tampa’s ability to keep the team together this offseason was in no small part thanks to how Greenberg set up the team’s cap; the Bucs had budgeted incredibly responsibly over the years, which allowed for them to stretch things this year.

    Tony Pastoors, Rams VP of football and business administration:The question with Pastoors, as it has been with Greenberg and Khan, is whether he’s on a GM track or a team president track. Either way, the ex-Dartmouth football player has a bright future. He’s responsible for the team’s salary cap, but really is in on every part of the team’s football operations, working closely with team COO Kevin Demoff.

    She’s just 32, and maybe a couple of years away, but she’s now in Berry’s old role in Philly, and Berry tried to take her to Cleveland with him. She has a law degree, ran contracts for the Toronto Argonauts, then became the Argos’ assistant GM and, for good measure, is fluent in three languages. And according to those who’ve worked with her, she’s capable in all facets of personnel. One ex-colleague of hers plainly said, “She will be the first female GM.”

    By Albert Breer/SI


    Albert Breer's latest compilation of 29 scouts and personnel experts preparing to take over a changing job description. Plus, the Week 17 preview.

  • ghost
    The Rise of Kellen Moore
    • Jun 2013
    • 5505
    • Send PM

    #2
    CBSSports Top GM candidates entering 2022


    Mike Borgonzi, Chiefs assistant GM: It's a matter of time before folks begin getting plucked out of the Chiefs front office, and I was surprised it didn't happen last year. Borgonzi has been a key part of Brett Veach's extremely successful group in KC. - CBSSports


    Kevin Abrams, Giants VP of football operations: If John Mara decides to stay within the Giants family for his next GM, Abrams is the odds-on favorite to be the pick after spending nearly a quarter-century with the franchise.

    Dawn Aponte, NFL chief football administrative officer: She's worked with the league's management council as well as in the front offices of the Jets, Browns and Dolphins. She's as well-rounded as any on this list to become a GM.


    Malik Boyd, Bills senior director of pro scouting: Boyd's been in the scouting ranks for nearly two decades. He got an interview for the Houston job last year.

    Brandon Brown, Eagles director of player personnel: One of the fastest "risers" in all of personnel. Brown played in college, has a law degree, a college coaching background, scouted for the Colts and oversees Philly's pro scouting department.

    Ran Carthon, 49ers director of player personnel: Carthon received this promotion last year and manages the Niners pro scouting department. A former NFL player, he ran the Rams pro personnel department before joining San Francisco five years ago.

    Glenn Cook, Browns VP of player personnel: Cook, a former stud linebacker at the University of Miami, has been an instrumental and quiet part of Cleveland's turnaround under GM Andrew Berry.

    Ryan Cowden, Titans VP of player personnel: Cowden took a successful career with the Carolina Panthers to Tennessee six years ago and has helped the Titans to three playoff appearances. He interviewed for the Washington GM last year.

    Jacqueline Davidson, Buccaneers director of football research: A highly respected member of Jason Licht's staff, Davidson has been key in the Bucs' cap decisions since Tom Brady arrived. Davidson, who has a law degree, spent 11 years with the Jets before helping make Tampa Bay into a Super Bowl champion.

    DuJuan Daniels, Raiders assistant director of player personnel: A longtime member of the Patriots scouting department, Daniels joined Mike Mayock's group in 2019. If Mark Davis makes a move at GM, he should be an internal candidate.

    Ed Dodds, Colts assistant GM: Dodds was highly coveted last offseason but had the privilege of waiting for the right job. If the right one opens up this offseason, I'd expect him to be a top candidate.

    Mike Greenberg, Buccaneers VP of football administration: Greenberg got the promotion after the Super Bowl victory and has been at the control of all the contract and cap situations.

    Khai Harley, Saints VP of football administration: The Saints have done more cap gymnastics the last seven-or-so years than any other team in football. Harley, who's been with the team for a decade and a half, is to thank for that. He's one of the quietest candidates on this list, but he's one of its most effective as well.

    Quentin Harris, Cardinals VP of player personnel: A former Cardinals safety, he's been in Arizona's scouting department for 14 years and got the promotion to VP this past offseason.

    Joe Hortiz, Ravens director of player personnel: He's been a top lieutenant for Ozzie Newsome and Eric DeCosta for years, and he's been in this role for seven seasons. Hortiz is very well respected in the college scouting community.

    Brandon Hunt, Steelers pro scouting coordinator: Hunt has been a top candidate to replace Kevin Colbert should he move on. Being part of a team that, up to this point, has had no losing seasons should mean something to team owners hoping to establish consistent success.

    Jeff Ireland, Saints assistant GM: Those stellar Saints drafts the last several years? Yeah, that's Ireland. Enough time has passed since his tenure as Dolphins GM where he should get a serious look at another top gig.

    Dwayne Joseph, Raiders director of pro personnel: Joseph has been in pro scouting for 20 years. If and when the Bears GM job comes open, he's likely to get a call there.

    Will McClay, Cowboys EVP of player personnel: McClay has been the engine that makes the personnel department go the last several years. It's a matter of time before someone gets him out of Dallas and into his own role as a top dog.

    Dan Morgan, Panthers assistant GM: The former All-Pro linebacker just joined the Panthers staff in this role after serving three years as the Bills director of player personnel and should get GM looks soon.

    Champ Kelly, Bears assistant director of player personnel: He was previously a finalist for the Jets job that went to Joe Douglas. Kelly impressed many around the league this summer in a presentation he gave during the Ozzie Newsome GM Forum.

    Trent Kirchner, Seahawks VP of player personnel: He was a GM candidate for the Texans last year and the Colts before that.

    Adam Peters, 49ers assistant GM: Peters was a finalist for the Panthers gig last season and was promoted to AGM shortly after that. He's logged 18 years in the NFL.

    John Spytek, Buccaneers VP of player personnel: The third name (listed alphabetically, remember) from this Bucs front office on this list. He has nearly two decades in the league with a previous stop in Denver as a national scout during their run with Peyton Manning.

    Eric Stokes, Washington Football Team senior director of player personnel: Stokes is a well-respected scout who spent time as Miami's AGM in 2014 and 2015.

    Samir Suleiman, Panthers director of player negotiations and salary cap manager: Team owner David Tepper plucked Suleiman from Pittsburgh to be Carolina's numbers guru and he hasn't disappointed.

    Tim Terry, Chiefs senior director of pro personnel: A former NFL linebacker who spent 13 seasons with the Packers before helping build the Chiefs into a Super Bowl winner.

    Eliot Wolf, Patriots consultant: Ron Wolf's son has been consulting in New England since 2020. His name has been attached to a potential opening in Vegas.

    JoJo Wooden, Chargers director of player personnel: He's been running the successful player personnel department with the Chargers since 2013 under GM Tom Telesco.

    Comment

    • Bolt4Knob
      Registered Charger Fan
      • Dec 2019
      • 12297
      • Send PM

      #3
      Well - that would also probably mean Staley is gone
      With that - my GM candidate would be the person that Sean Payton recommends
      if not - the guy from the Ravens, Horvitz

      Comment

      • ghost
        The Rise of Kellen Moore
        • Jun 2013
        • 5505
        • Send PM

        #4
        Here are the new GMs in 2022:

        Kwesi Adofo-Mensah, Minnesota Vikings: The analytics community was initially thrilled to see Adofo-Mensah hired from Cleveland, but then grumbled after he made some moves typical of most general managers, like kicking the Kirk Cousins can down the road and signing Za'Darius Smith. This may be a hot take, but I think trying to win is #good. Give the man some time.

        Trent Baalke, Jacksonville Jaguars: The Jaguars made the curious decision to elevate Baalke following the more curious decision to hire Urban Meyer. It was even more surprising that the team kept Baalke this year, rather than completely starting over. He spent the Jaguars' money in free agency like a man who knows he's not guaranteed to have the company credit card forever.

        Nick Caserio, Houston Texans: It's early to evaluate Caserio's tenure, but it's not a great sign that he's already on his second head coach in as many years. The picks acquired in the Deshaun Watson trade should help speed up a rebuilding process which has mostly felt like wheel-spinning beyond a possible draft steal in quarterback Davis Mills.

        Scott Fitterer, Carolina Panthers: Fitterer took over in January 2021, a year after coach Matt Rhule came aboard. So far, he's been part of a disastrous Sam Darnold trade, two underwhelming free agency periods and a draft that didn't bear immediate fruit. Passing on Justin Fields and Mac Jones looks worse a year later with the quarterback need even more pronounced.

        Terry Fontenot, Atlanta Falcons: The decision to draft tight end Kyle Pitts over quarterbacks Justin Fields and Mac Jones will likely define this era of Falcons football. The team's failed effort to acquire Deshaun Watson, which led to Atlanta getting less than full value in a Matt Ryan trade, puts the Falcons' long-term process into question. It feels like the first two years of the Fontenot-Arthur Smith era could be largely about clearing away old mistakes.

        Brad Holmes, Detroit Lions: Unlike Fontenot in Atlanta, Holmes' first year in Detroit hit all the right rebuild notes. The Lions compiled a promising coaching staff and began to find young players to build around. Now they just have to do it again and they could be contending by Year 3.

        Ryan Poles, Chicago Bears: While other teams surround their young quarterbacks with all the talent possible, Justin Fields' offensive line still looks shaky and there aren't a lot of players for him to throw to beyond Darnell Mooney. Poles' first draft should be about helping his QB.

        Joe Schoen, New York Giants:AFC WEST

        Dave Ziegler, Las Vegas Raiders: Ziegler and Josh McDaniel are tied at the hip. If the duo's early transactions -- from Chandler Jones to Davante Adams -- are any indication, the Raiders will be more willing to make bold moves for top-tier talent than McDaniels' old boss in Foxborough.

        George Paton, Denver Broncos: Hired last January, Paton passed on Justin Fields and Mac Jones for Patrick Surtain II. Surtain's terrific rookie season and -- crucially -- the Russell Wilson trade suddenly make that look very wise. It's easy to imagine Paton debuting on the rankings portion of this piece fairly high up a year from now.


        I've been very complimentary of GM George Paton up until now. He has made three brutal mistakes in a row with 1) the hiring of Hackett, 2) Wilson Trade, & 3) Wilson contract. If he can get out from under both contracts, he will survive and flourish. If not, it doesn't look very promising.

        Ziegler is new and I can't judge him on a 3-7 start. Needs time to reshape the roster and he has it.

        Comment

        • ghost
          The Rise of Kellen Moore
          • Jun 2013
          • 5505
          • Send PM

          #5
          When is it time to talk about Telesco's tenure? At the 10-year mark seems the perfect point to stop and evaluate, don't you agree?

          Comment

          • ghost
            The Rise of Kellen Moore
            • Jun 2013
            • 5505
            • Send PM

            #6
            Originally posted by Bolt4Knob View Post
            Well - that would also probably mean Staley is gone
            With that - my GM candidate would be the person that Sean Payton recommends
            if not - the guy from the Ravens, Horvitz
            Ravens Director of Player Personnel Joe Hortiz talked about the strengths of the class and the benefit of the combine returning.


            2022 1 1 14 14 Kyle Hamilton DB Notre Dame
            2 1 25 25 Tyler Linderbaum C Iowa
            3 2 13 45 David Ojabo LB Michigan
            4 3 12 76 Travis Jones DT Connecticut
            5 4 5 110 Daniel Faalele T Minnesota
            6 4 14 119 Jalyn Armour-Davis DB Alabama
            7 4 23 128 Charlie Kolar TE Iowa State
            8 4 25 130 Jordan Stout P Penn State
            9 4 34 139 Isaiah Likely TE Coastal Carolina
            10 4 36 141 Damarion Williams DB Houston
            11 6 17 196 Tyler Badie RB Missouri
            Ravens took two TEs in Kolar and Likely.

            Comment

            • ghost
              The Rise of Kellen Moore
              • Jun 2013
              • 5505
              • Send PM

              #7
              NFL readers Q&A

              Doesn’t appear that any of the defensive backs the Chargers either drafted or signed through free agency have done or are capable of doing anything worthwhile, so who is accountable? Is it all on [general manager Tom] Telesco or does Staley also bear responsibility for the choices?

              Alan Minton, Dallas

              Jeff Miller/LATimes: I’d argue Derwin James Jr. is pretty good. Asante Samuel Jr. has a chance to be very good. Still too early to conclude that he’s incapable of doing anything worthwhile. J.C. Jackson was a Pro Bowl pick last year and didn’t have much of a chance to show himself this season before he got hurt. Ultimately, Tom Telesco and Brandon Staley are most responsible for the construction of this roster. The most disappointing thing about the 2022 Chargers for me has been the struggles of the defense overall. We heard all offseason about how they had added players with the experience and body types necessary to succeed in this scheme. The results through 10 games have been wildly mixed.

              Wildly mixed = Worst run defense in league since 2000.

              Comment

              • chargeroo
                Fan since 1961
                • Jan 2019
                • 4739
                • Oregon
                • Retired Manager/Pastor
                • Send PM

                #8
                The top of the list for taking over as the Charger's GM would probably be John Spanos. Are you ready for that?
                THE YEAR OF THE FLIP!

                Comment

                • Velo
                  Ride!
                  • Aug 2019
                  • 10979
                  • Everywhere
                  • Leave the gun, take the cannolis
                  • Send PM

                  #9
                  My candidate for GM in 2023 is Tom Telesco, because I already know it's going to be him.

                  Comment

                  • Bolt-O
                    Administrator
                    • Jun 2013
                    • 32238
                    • Send PM

                    #10
                    Originally posted by chargeroo View Post
                    The top of the list for taking over as the Charger's GM would probably be John Spanos. Are you ready for that?
                    I don't think it would be John specifically, but would be a promote from within... JoJo Wooden.

                    Comment

                    • ghost
                      The Rise of Kellen Moore
                      • Jun 2013
                      • 5505
                      • Send PM

                      #11


                      Chiefs director of football operations Mike Borgonzi discusses the Chiefs 2021 draft. Borgonzi is the guy, IMO.

                      2021 1 2 26 58 Nick Bolton LB Missouri
                      2 2 31 63 Creed Humphrey C Oklahoma
                      3 4 39 144 Joshua Kaindoh DE Florida State
                      4 5 18 162 Noah Gray TE Duke
                      5 5 37 181 Cornell Powell WR Clemson
                      6 6 42 226 Trey Smith G Tennessee

                      Comment

                      • chargeroo
                        Fan since 1961
                        • Jan 2019
                        • 4739
                        • Oregon
                        • Retired Manager/Pastor
                        • Send PM

                        #12
                        Originally posted by Bolt-O View Post

                        I don't think it would be John specifically, but would be a promote from within... JoJo Wooden.
                        Who would Dean prefer?
                        I can see it now, General Manager John Spanos.

                        At least we could be sure who we're blaming then.
                        THE YEAR OF THE FLIP!

                        Comment

                        Working...
                        X