Official 2026 Chargers News | Acquisitions | Transactions | Injuries

Collapse
This is a sticky topic.
X
X
Collapse
First Prev Next Last
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Velo
    Ride!
    • Aug 2019
    • 16000
    • Everywhere
    • Leave the gun, take the cannolis
    • Send PM

    #22453
    Originally posted by dmac_bolt View Post

    8 sacks in the last 2 seasons is not worth this year's 4th imo. Original draft slot or first year production no longer matters when you post up two seasons like that in a row. jmo, I would certainly welcome him (> Bud).
    He is a legit top 15 talent IMO. He was 4th in DROY voting in 2022 and had a stand out soph season. He's only 25, his lack of production the past two seasons can be attributable to factors within the Giants like Oweh with the Ravens. For a 4th the Chargers would get a bookend to Tuli that would make one of the best edge duos in the league for a long time. They could fill that need for a pass rusher for a 3rd day pick and use their day 1-2 picks for other purposes. It makes sense to me.

    Comment

    • powderblueboy
      Registered Charger Fan
      • Jul 2017
      • 14129
      • Send PM

      #22454
      Thibodeaux has missed 12 games the last 2 years. His 2024 tape is as good as 2023 (the 11.5 sack year) ... he missed 5 games.

      Comment

      • powderblueboy
        Registered Charger Fan
        • Jul 2017
        • 14129
        • Send PM

        #22455
        Originally posted by Velo View Post

        He is a legit top 15 talent IMO. He was 4th in DROY voting in 2022 and had a stand out soph season. He's only 25, his lack of production the past two seasons can be attributable to factors within the Giants like Oweh with the Ravens. For a 4th the Chargers would get a bookend to Tuli that would make one of the best edge duos in the league for a long time. They could fill that need for a pass rusher for a 3rd day pick and use their day 1-2 picks for other purposes.He It makes sense to me.
        On a one year contract? This is his 5th year, so he will cost a bit this year as a 1rst rounder.

        Comment

        • Bolt4Knob
          Registered Charger Fan
          • Dec 2019
          • 20037
          • Send PM

          #22456
          Originally posted by powderblueboy View Post

          On a one year contract? This is his 5th year, so he will cost a bit this year as a 1rst rounder.
          If this story is true, I think its more fan blogger and not an actual real trade - but if true, same thing as Oweh, $14m for one year and you have a decision next year. In this case, just draft the Edge player. Keep the pick.

          Comment

          • CanadianBoltFan
            Registered Charger Fan
            • Jul 2022
            • 10938
            • White Rock, BC Canada
            • Send PM

            #22457
            Originally posted by Bolt4Knob View Post

            I think the LB room is fine. What would be a "good" solution if they only keep 5 is that Colson beats out Perryman. Or if they keep 6, Colson plays well enough that maybe Perryman is inactive, signed to the PS for depth.
            You can always improve any room in the draft, especially if you are following the BPA formula. But the Chargers have left themselves with much bigger roster needs than LB and have only 5 picks so i just can't see drafting a LB.

            Comment

            • beachcomber
              & ramblin' man
              • Jan 2019
              • 7114
              • Send PM

              #22458
              Originally posted by Bolt4Knob View Post

              I think the LB room is fine. What would be a "good" solution if they only keep 5 is that Colson beats out Perryman. Or if they keep 6, Colson plays well enough that maybe Perryman is inactive, signed to the PS for depth.
              just have a hard time fathoming these repeatedly absurd posts, and…. based on what exactly ??

              this is the reasoning, or lack thereof, that leaves a roster in shambles…. are we still hoping for a 7th WR ??
              LB CJ Allen, LT Caleb Lomu, OC Parker Brailsford, RB Demond Claiborne, TE Justin Joly, NT Dontay Corleone,​​ OC Bryce Foster, CB Josh Moten, LB Eric Gentry

              Comment

              • Maniaque 6
                French Speaking Charger Fan
                • Jan 2019
                • 4264
                • Québec city
                • Send PM

                #22459
                Originally posted by CanadianBoltFan View Post

                You can always improve any room in the draft, especially if you are following the BPA formula. But the Chargers have left themselves with much bigger roster needs than LB and have only 5 picks so i just can't see drafting a LB.
                If you are following the BPA formula, you don't draft a LB at 22 this year !

                Comment

                • dmac_bolt
                  Stunt Sniffer
                  • May 2019
                  • 21030
                  • Los Barrios del San Marcos
                  • Send PM

                  #22460
                  Originally posted by Maniaque 6 View Post

                  If you are following the BPA formula, you don't draft a LB at 22 this year !
                  Nor if you follow the position value formula any year
                  Justin Herbert 2026 MVP Watch

                  Comment

                  • CanadianBoltFan
                    Registered Charger Fan
                    • Jul 2022
                    • 10938
                    • White Rock, BC Canada
                    • Send PM

                    #22461
                    Originally posted by Maniaque 6 View Post

                    If you are following the BPA formula, you don't draft a LB at 22 this year !
                    I meant with only 5 picks and many other more pressing needs they can't really be drafting a LB with any pick

                    Comment

                    • Bolt4Knob
                      Registered Charger Fan
                      • Dec 2019
                      • 20037
                      • Send PM

                      #22462
                      Originally posted by beachcomber View Post

                      just have a hard time fathoming these repeatedly absurd posts, and…. based on what exactly ??

                      this is the reasoning, or lack thereof, that leaves a roster in shambles…. are we still hoping for a 7th WR ??
                      Are you saying its absurd to think Colson will make the jump to being a contributor going into his 3rd season? This has merit - Colson has done nothing in two years

                      Or, are you saying that if the 3rd round pick plays to his potential in year 3, combined with improved play from Wax and Phillips, thereby putting Perryman on the bubble - would be a bad thing for the roster?

                      As for the 7th WR -- the room can be improved from last year -- Ladd is good, QJ, improving, the other four haven't shown enough to say the room can't improve.

                      Comment

                      • electricgold
                        Registered Charger Fan
                        • Apr 2020
                        • 3812
                        • Send PM

                        #22463
                        Originally posted by Bolt4Knob View Post

                        Are you saying its absurd to think Colson will make the jump to being a contributor going into his 3rd season? This has merit - Colson has done nothing in two years

                        Or, are you saying that if the 3rd round pick plays to his potential in year 3, combined with improved play from Wax and Phillips, thereby putting Perryman on the bubble - would be a bad thing for the roster?

                        As for the 7th WR -- the room can be improved from last year -- Ladd is good, QJ, improving, the other four haven't shown enough to say the room can't improve.
                        We definitely should try and dump QJ for a burner deep threat wr!

                        8 to 9 TD seasons from QJ fine! But he has not been good enough in every other area especially being a first round draft pick. Time to upgrade.

                        Comment

                        • Ghost of Quacksaw
                          Beef Before Gazelles
                          • May 2021
                          • 5015
                          • Send PM

                          #22464
                          I'm accepting of the idea that the BPA at #22 could very well *not* be an interior o-lineman.

                          There are different directions that Joe Hortiz could go in this circumstance: BPA might be a Front 7 Defender, in which case, problem solved!

                          The *problem* comes if Joe's Board has a BPA who plays a 'less necessary' position, in terms of the Chargers' specific needs. Say, for example, that Oregon TE Kenyon Sadiq is that guy.

                          If- in this scenario-- Joe Hortiz took Sadiq, the reaction on this forum would be chaotic, and range from rational to cataclysmic.

                          All I can say is that Joe has made solid picks the majority of the time. If Sadiq (or other lesser-position-of-need guy) is the choice? I'm not going to have a cardiac event over it. I would trust that Joe is not an idiot and knows what he's doing.

                          Besides, if Joe chose poorly? I can always have my cardiac event later.

                          Comment

                          Working...