Chargers @ Chiefs Wk3 Game Day Thread / Post Game Discussion

[jamrock]

Penalty eliminates catch or drop.
‘I must be thinking of the wrong play by the other posts I’m reading.

You’re thinking of the 4th and 9 play. Also a drop but got a flag

[Ghost of Quacksaw]

Palmer is not a separate discussion when others have been touting him from Day 1 as a player that will fully replace Mike Williams. Medieval peasants were closer to flying to the moon than Palmer is to fully replacing Williams.

Of course Palmer is a separate discussion! Just because fans touted him as Williams' replacement doesn't mean it's what Telesco has planned. I don't see Palmer's future tied to Williams.

[Guest]

Penalty eliminates catch or drop.
‘I must be thinking of the wrong play by the other posts I’m reading.

Yeah, there was no penalty on that play. You may be thinking of the 4th down play on the last drive where Guyton got mugged.

[Guest]

The issue with our offense right now is our red zone offense which looks better after the Chiefs game, but should still trend upward. It’s hard to criticize the play calling when this has been our best game offensively so far. You’re nitpicking.

Not nitpicking. This was the very thing that killed our offense and cost us games last year. It matters and matters a lot.

[Xenos]

Why be predictable either way?
I don’t want opponents passrushers pinning their ears back from snap 1 to snap 70.

That’s what happened to Buffalo last year in the playoffs.

[Guest]

Of course Palmer is a separate discussion! Just because fans touted him as Williams' replacement doesn't mean it's what Telesco has planned. I don't see Palmer's future tied to Williams.

Either Palmer was drafted to be a reserve WR with no eye toward replacing Mike Williams or he was drafted to replace Mike Williams. If he was simply drafted to be a reserve WR, the pick was a bad one because we already had solid reserve WRs.

If he was drafted to replace Mike Williams, the pick was a bad one because Palmer cannot fully replace Mike Williams. He lacks the talent to do so.

Either way, the pick was bad.

[Guest]

I have no idea what a scorer charged him with drop/no drop. As someone who played QB you better believe if I put a ball that a receiver got both hands on and didn't catch it, it wa a drop.

I looked it up. Per NBC Sports, Guyton has one scored drop in 3 games, less than Allen, Williams and Cook. though Allen and Williams have many more targets.

[Xenos]

Either Palmer was drafted to be a reserve WR with no eye toward replacing Mike Williams or he was drafted to replace Mike Williams. If we was simply drafted to be a reserve WR, the pick was a bad one because we already had solid reserve WRs.

If he was drafted to replace Mike Williams, the pick was a bad one because Palmer cannot fully replace Mike Williams. He lacks the talent to do so.

Either way, the pick was bad.

[Xenos]

Not nitpicking. This was the very thing that killed our offense and cost us games last year. It matters and matters a lot.

It’s okay to be wrong sometimes. Not everyone can be right all the time like me.

[Ghost of Quacksaw]

Either Palmer was drafted to be a reserve WR with no eye toward replacing Mike Williams or he was drafted to replace Mike Williams. If we was simply drafted to be a reserve WR, the pick was a bad one because we already had solid reserve WRs.

If he was drafted to replace Mike Williams, the pick was a bad one because Palmer cannot fully replace Mike Williams. He lacks the talent to do so.

Either way, the pick was bad.

You've made up your mind about it, for sure.

[Guest]

So your preference is for us to pick reserve players that do not help our team. Got it.

[Guest]

It’s okay to be wrong sometimes. Not everyone can be right all the time like me.

Re-watch the 2020 season. You should see the problem I am discussing when you do so.