Official 2026 Chargers Roster Discussion | Roster Build | Free Agency

Collapse
This is a sticky topic.
X
X
Collapse
First Prev Next Last
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Riverwalk
    Registered Charger Fan
    • Nov 2021
    • 6096
    • Send PM

    #3817
    Originally posted by sonorajim View Post

    Point being?
    I was responding to the declaration Hart and Still are the best 5th round picks ever as evidenced by their CB performance versus the Browns.

    I'll wait until I see how they do against Burrow providing they don't get benched if our two starters return.

    This best ever gushing about Minter, DB's, or whoever is like some drooling billionaire owner thinking he got a genius HC just because he was DC of the #1 defense the year before.

    You all forget that about Staley?

    Comment

    • Guest

      #3818
      Originally posted by Riverwalk View Post

      I was responding to the declaration Hart and Still are the best 5th round picks ever as evidenced by their CB performance versus the Browns.

      I'll wait until I see how they do against Burrow providing they don't get benched if our two starters return.

      This best ever gushing about Minter, DB's, or whoever is like some drooling billionaire owner thinking he got a genius HC just because he was DC of the #1 defense the year before.

      You all forget that about Staley?
      Not even remotely comparable. You sound like the old chain crusher, taking a contrary viewpoint just to get a rise out of people.

      Comment

      • Riverwalk
        Registered Charger Fan
        • Nov 2021
        • 6096
        • Send PM

        #3819
        Originally posted by captaind View Post

        Not even remotely comparable. You sound like the old chain crusher, taking a contrary viewpoint just to get a rise out of people.
        I don't get how Staley coaching the #1 defense is irrelevant.

        If you bother to go back, this forum was gushing just as hard about Staley when he was hired as Minter after 8 games against powder puffs.

        All I'm saying is lets see how the defense holds up against the best offenses we will face down the stretch starting with the Bengals and save a seat on the bus for me.

        Comment

        • Boltjolt
          Dont let the PBs fool ya
          • Jun 2013
          • 34064
          • Henderson, NV
          • Send PM

          #3820
          Originally posted by Riverwalk View Post

          Perhaps you were ball watching because there were several receivers due to broken coverage running free as a bird that Winston mysteriously didn't see.

          Geez....even the announcers pointed it out. Did you have the sound off too?
          You see that every week with QBs. They can't possibly see every open receiver with the given time they have and the progressions. Winston isn't exactly a scrambler.

          Id have to see those receivers you say are so open though to agree because on one play I saw one but Winston would have no chance to change his position to throw to him so I can't count that one.

          Comment

          • sonorajim
            Registered Charger Fan
            • Jan 2019
            • 9833
            • Send PM

            #3821
            Originally posted by Riverwalk View Post

            I was responding to the declaration Hart and Still are the best 5th round picks ever as evidenced by their CB performance versus the Browns.

            I'll wait until I see how they do against Burrow providing they don't get benched if our two starters return.

            This best ever gushing about Minter, DB's, or whoever is like some drooling billionaire owner thinking he got a genius HC just because he was DC of the #1 defense the year before.

            You all forget that about Staley?
            The comparison is weak. Staley was a flash in the pan one year with LAR. Looked very inconsistent with LAC.
            Minter had very similar success in college and as an assistant with the Ravens.
            Surely you admit that the Chargers defense is playing very well indeed?
            Is he the best in NFL history remains to be established.
            The best record in the 2024 NFL to this point is an established fact.
            Can it continue? Yes. Will it? Maybe. I wish him well.

            Comment

            • Riverwalk
              Registered Charger Fan
              • Nov 2021
              • 6096
              • Send PM

              #3822
              Originally posted by sonorajim View Post

              The comparison is weak. Staley was a flash in the pan one year with LAR. Looked very inconsistent with LAC.
              Minter had very similar success in college and as an assistant with the Ravens.
              Surely you admit that the Chargers defense is playing very well indeed?
              Is he the best in NFL history remains to be established.
              The best record in the 2024 NFL to this point is an established fact.
              Can it continue? Yes. Will it? Maybe. I wish him well.
              "Maybe" I cosign.

              I'm just not ready to send that bust of Minter to Canton like the same posters wanted to do with Staley when he first arrived.

              Comment

              • Bolt4Knob
                Registered Charger Fan
                • Dec 2019
                • 20105
                • Send PM

                #3823
                Originally posted by Riverwalk View Post

                "Maybe" I cosign.

                I'm just not ready to send that bust of Minter to Canton like the same posters wanted to do with Staley when he first arrived.
                I agree. I think Minter needs to show it for a couple, three years. I would be leery of hiring him after one year. Plus, the job is head football coach - just not Sr Defensive Coordinator. That said, he is doing a helluva job

                I cannot take credit for the name - but Haglund on Twitter/X mentioned Lawrence from the Cowboys

                Interesting thought - Cowboys won't be able to pay him next year with their cap --they also have to pay Micah -- so might be a good trade candidate

                TE
                IOL
                DL
                CB

                Hortiz has many ways he can go

                Comment

                • Riverwalk
                  Registered Charger Fan
                  • Nov 2021
                  • 6096
                  • Send PM

                  #3824
                  Originally posted by Bolt4Knob View Post

                  I agree. I think Minter needs to show it for a couple, three years. I would be leery of hiring him after one year. Plus, the job is head football coach - just not Sr Defensive Coordinator. That said, he is doing a helluva job

                  I cannot take credit for the name - but Haglund on Twitter/X mentioned Lawrence from the Cowboys

                  Interesting thought - Cowboys won't be able to pay him next year with their cap --they also have to pay Micah -- so might be a good trade candidate

                  TE
                  IOL
                  DL
                  CB

                  Hortiz has many ways he can go
                  I agree. I'm impressed so far.

                  Comment

                  • sonorajim
                    Registered Charger Fan
                    • Jan 2019
                    • 9833
                    • Send PM

                    #3825
                    Originally posted by Riverwalk View Post

                    "Maybe" I cosign.

                    I'm just not ready to send that bust of Minter to Canton like the same posters wanted to do with Staley when he first arrived.
                    I was hopeful with Staley but didn't feel much like gushing after 8 games into his 1st Chargers season.
                    "Minter to Canton" is a possibility that seems remote today. That will take several years of consistently being one of the best if not THE Best in the NFL.
                    But, he has gotten off to a nice start.

                    Comment

                    • foreigner
                      Tom Telesco is gone
                      • Sep 2013
                      • 2248
                      • Send PM

                      #3826
                      Titans, Bengals, Ravens, Falcons, Chiefs, Bucs, Broncos, Pats and Raiturds.... The remaining schedule looks complicated, brace yourself! we are in for a ride!

                      Comment

                      • Critty
                        Dominate the Day.
                        • Mar 2019
                        • 6757
                        • Send PM

                        #3827
                        Trade deadline.
                        If somehow Hortiz could trade Bosa and a bunch of picks for M.Garrett that would be champions level.
                        Who has it better than us?

                        Comment

                        • cmplxgal
                          Registered Charger Fan
                          • Jul 2017
                          • 2329
                          • New Jersey
                          • Send PM

                          #3828

                          Comment

                          Working...