Justin Herbert - Bolts Franchise QB Official Discussion

[powderblueboy]

Yeah, saying Brady " got lucky" is ridiculous.
Dude won 7 Lombardi's.
That aIn't lucky fellas.....it's GREATNESS!
Whilst I was never a Brady fan( how could anyone outside of NE be????), gotta respect the hardware.
Until another QB comes along and has as much " luck", can we stop the nonsense about TB being fortunate or lucky? The football IQ around here is too high for such childish banter.

Brady won the trophies by himself, or was it the Patriot organization?

He was put in a great position (see my last post) and made the most of it .... for sure.

[sonorajim]

Brady won the trophies by himself, or was it the Patriot organization?

He was put in a great position (see my last post) and made the most of it .... for sure.

Team. I saw BB win an NFL game with Special Teams once with Brady out. Brady, BB and the OL coach Dante Scarneccia were all special in their own right. Together? GOAT.

[NoMoreChillies]

I think Brady won becuase he was soo good not lucky. He split and won again with another team, something BB hasnt done.

[DerwinBosa]

I think Brady won becuase he was soo good not lucky. He split and won again with another team, something BB hasnt done.

Belichick hasn't won a Super Bowl without Brady, but the Patriots won the 2001 AFC Championship after Brady left with an injury early in the game. The defense and Belichick's coaching had more to do with the Patriots' first three Super Bowl wins. The same is true in 2018, when they beat the Rams 13-3 in the Super Bowl.

As far as Brady winning a Super Bowl with Tampa Bay, I'm not sure his three interceptions against Green Bay in the NFC Championship Game, followed by the Bucs' defense destroying Kansas City's backup offensive line, should be considered all that impressive.

[sonorajim]

I think Brady won becuase he was soo good not lucky. He split and won again with another team, something BB hasnt done.

Brady won in NE 'cause he was good-great with a great HC and owner. He won in TB 'cause he was good- great and wanted to prove something on a basic one-shot deal.
He made his point but it was kind of a set-up. No way in heck he could have gone just anywhere and done the same. IMO.

[northerner]

Belichick hasn't won a Super Bowl without Brady, but the Patriots won the 2001 AFC Championship after Brady left with an injury early in the game. The defense and Belichick's coaching had more to do with the Patriots' first three Super Bowl wins. The same is true in 2018, when they beat the Rams 13-3 in the Super Bowl.

As far as Brady winning a Super Bowl with Tampa Bay, I'm not sure his three interceptions against Green Bay in the NFC Championship Game, followed by the Bucs' defense destroying Kansas City's backup offensive line, should be considered all that impressive.

he tried to give that game away, and the TB defense saved him. the history books only show: Brady won.

he is one of the greatest, but i'm not giving the GOAT title. what Mahomes has done EVERY YEAR, is really impressive - and he has been a one-man demolition crew (passes and runs).

[sonorajim]

he tried to give that game away, and the TB defense saved him. the history books only show: Brady won.

he is one of the greatest, but i'm not giving the GOAT title. what Mahomes has done EVERY YEAR, is really impressive - and he has been a one-man demolition crew (passes and runs).

Let him play QB for Head Coach Staley and we'll see how great he is.

[Maniaque 6]

he tried to give that game away, and the TB defense saved him. the history books only show: Brady won.

he is one of the greatest, but i'm not giving the GOAT title. what Mahomes has done EVERY YEAR, is really impressive - and he has been a one-man demolition crew (passes and runs).

Remember Joe Cool ?

[jamrock]

According to ESPN, NFL players think Justin Herbert is the 4 th most overrated QB

https://x.com/nfl_dovkleiman/status/1828606675848438057?s=46&t=Dee5034k4BrrXe6U-h5bEA

[Boltjolt]

According to ESPN, NFL players think Justin Herbert is the 4 th most overrated QB

https://x.com/nfl_dovkleiman/status/...4BrrXe6U-h5bEA

That's gonna change

[Boltgang74]

According to ESPN, NFL players think Justin Herbert is the 4 th most overrated QB

https://x.com/nfl_dovkleiman/status/...4BrrXe6U-h5bEA

Those are mostly solid QBs on that list.

[ChargersPowderBlue]

Those are mostly solid QBs on that list.

I do agree about Josh Allen. He is so overrated.

I would have Brock Purdy and Kyler Murray higher.