Tweet
Originally posted by richpjr
View Post
-
Its pretty fucking awesome. And 50 full pages written by just one guy, anyone know the record?“Less is more? NO NO NO - MORE is MORE!” -
-
In comparison, the Herbert thread frankly sucks.
Maybe Herbert could start insulting the legal profession to get things humming there.Comment
-
-
Sorry guys, I was the one who opened the Josh Palmer thread back up. I did it because of all the buzz I've heard about him going into year 2. Let's let Chaincrusher have his opinion. I can't say he's wrong, and I can't say he's right. We just have to wait and see. I'm not gonna make any WR3 predictions, because honestly, either could take it. I'm not patient enough to see why Chaincrusher takes Guyton over Palmer, but that's his opinion. I don't see anything wrong with that. Plus, we've seen 2 years of Guyton play over 1 year of Palmer play. I just hope the better man wins, whomever that may be.Comment
-
Trust me i like big threads. I like great debates. I dont like personal attacks and insulting each others intrellect. And if i warn about these things and they go unchecked...i have to draw a line. Im not a hardass....i just have to try and look at this community as a whole and some are really over the flame wars between CC and others.
So lets chill out and debate without crossing the line? AlohaComment
-
-
-
-
Josh Palmer’s car is faster ...Comment
-
It is hilarious that you think Huntley could not be a pass more from the pocket just because he played in BAL's offense. At Utah, as a senior Huntley completed 73.1% of his passes and produced a 10.3 YPA for over 3,000 yards with a 19-4 TD-INT ratio. In the NFL last year, he completed 64.9% of his passes and his QBR was 49.0. In the same offense, former NFL MVP Lamar Jackson completed 64.0% of his passes and had a QBR of 52.0.Originally posted by dmac_bolt View Post
The point regarding Montana and Young is that Montana and Young were clearly very different QBs, which you claim is a poor approach. That Young later took over as the starter is totally irrelevant to the point being made. Nobody ever said that Huntley is Steve Young. You are just making up crap because I showed one of numerous examples of how your theory that the starting QB and QB2 need to be similar is complete BS.
Also, I specifically stated that I wanted our QB2 to be able to be an effective runner as a potential change of pace to Herbert. That did not mean that I did not want to be able to pass the ball competently as well. Only your strange interpretation of what I said could twist it into that.
Finally, your post regarding Guyton demonstrates a lack of understanding about how our 2020 and 2021 offenses worked in terms of using Guyton. Last year, the offense threw more shorter passes to Guyton because Lombardi called short pass heavy games to the point that he was criticized by the national sports media for not letting Herbert throw more down the field as Herbert was at one point last year in the bottom 5 in air yards per attempts. In 2020, Guyton had more very deep receptions because even Steichen figured out that Guyton was a deep threat that should be exploited.Comment
-
I appreciate that. Also, I think people on this forum are going to be happy because I think that the team will give more WR3 snaps to Palmer this year than Guyton. I think the team will be making a mistake when they do so for the reasons I have stated in this thread, but I will be happy if Palmer breaks out as a player this year so that I could be wrong about him. I just honestly do not see Palmer's game getting dramatically better based upon what I perceive to be his fairly limited skillset. Some people think very highly of him, but I just see a solid reserve WR and not much more than that.Originally posted by Pat_Swindle View PostComment
Comment