Originally posted by dmac_bolt
View Post
Coach Staley Discussion - Fired
Collapse
This topic is closed.
X
X
-
- Top
- Bottom
-
-
Originally posted by NOrvMeNow View PostIf Belichick becomes the next Charger head coach and things go south,
could you imagine how brutal this forum would be on him?
All the hatred towards the Super Bowl Cheatriots magnified ten-fold.
It would almost be worth it.
would be brutal. Luckily Belichek is good at winning.
- Top
- Bottom
Leave a comment:
-
-
Originally posted by Bolt4Knob View Post
What I am against - more than anything - is the flavor of the month hot Coordinator (offense or defense) with like two years or less experience as a coordinator with a very small resume to fall back on. Kellen Moore falls under that almost as much as say Staley. Moore has only been an assistant since 2018.
For say Zach Taylor there is a Kliff Kingsbury - -of course the front office has helped in Cincy while in AZ - that was almost a Charger like cluster. So the organization matters. But for sure, a Kyle Shanahan type would be awesome but a few things about Kyle Shanahan compared to say Ben Johnson - Shanahan was an OC for 8 years before he got the gig with the Niners. Sure, he worked for his Dad part of the time but also was OC with the Browns (and we know what a crap show that was - but a great learning experience probably) as well as the Falcons
Ben Johnson - barely two years as an OC
Bobby Slowik - one year
Mike McDonalds Ravens DC - 8 years coaching total, one year as DC for Michigan and now one year for DC in Baltimore
Where is that Kyle Shanahan that has a crap load of experience and truly the only name that comes to mind is Eric Public (or Sleeping with) Bieniemy |__ __ | - the touchdown signal he used to do. Unless you hire Todd Monken type
- Top
- Bottom
Leave a comment:
-
-
Originally posted by NOrvMeNow View PostIf Belichick becomes the next Charger head coach and things go south,
could you imagine how brutal this forum would be on him?
All the hatred towards the Super Bowl Cheatriots magnified ten-fold.
It would almost be worth it.
I think the weirder part will be learning to love him when he installs a professional defense, hires professional offensive leaders, and manages game day decisions professionally and flips a 5-12 record to 12-5 in a single season with minimal roster changes.
- Top
- Bottom
Leave a comment:
-
-
Originally posted by jaguarmanftype View PostI still don't understand what this front office saw in year 1 of Staley's tenure to entrust him to go with the McVay approach and load up on a top heavy roster. If we had a top 5 defense and went deep into the playoffs in 2021, that's another matter, but truth be told, you should know what you have in a head coach within the first year of his tenure, and he had shown that he was no different from our previous forays.
As far as bringing in Belichick or some other Superbowl-winning head coach, I think history has proven that those tenures never lead a team to the promised land. Sure, Sean Payton would have made us a more interesting team, but it would probably be akin to the Dolphins in the Marino era. Belichick would be even more of a wildcard, and cost a lot more. I only see real prospects with Harbaugh since he has yet to win a Superbowl, but has shown a propensity to change culture and lead his teams to dominance.
Now that he will be available but Vrabel would be second
I probably have Quinn third - even ahead of Hoodie
Hoodie - well I would take him over a lot of candidates - but he would need a GM and maybe a different coaching staff - not so much nepotism with the family and friends plan
As for the plan with Staley - on paper the movies seemed good to me. Granted, it was pushing cap. But again, player evaluation with Tom John and Staley -its not good
- Top
- Bottom
Leave a comment:
-
-
I still don't understand what this front office saw in year 1 of Staley's tenure to entrust him to go with the McVay approach and load up on a top heavy roster. If we had a top 5 defense and went deep into the playoffs in 2021, that's another matter, but truth be told, you should know what you have in a head coach within the first year of his tenure, and he had shown that he was no different from our previous forays.
As far as bringing in Belichick or some other Superbowl-winning head coach, I think history has proven that those tenures never lead a team to the promised land. Sure, Sean Payton would have made us a more interesting team, but it would probably be akin to the Dolphins in the Marino era. Belichick would be even more of a wildcard, and cost a lot more. I only see real prospects with Harbaugh since he has yet to win a Superbowl, but has shown a propensity to change culture and lead his teams to dominance.
-
👍 2
- Top
- Bottom
Leave a comment:
-
-
Originally posted by NOrvMeNow View PostIf Belichick becomes the next Charger head coach and things go south,
could you imagine how brutal this forum would be on him?
All the hatred towards the Super Bowl Cheatriots magnified ten-fold.
It would almost be worth it.
- Top
- Bottom
Leave a comment:
-
-
If Belichick becomes the next Charger head coach and things go south,
could you imagine how brutal this forum would be on him?
All the hatred towards the Super Bowl Cheatriots magnified ten-fold.
It would almost be worth it.
- Top
- Bottom
Leave a comment:
-
-
Originally posted by CanadianBoltFan View Post
I hear you, of course it has to be a good offensive coach. We should have hired Payton after the playoff debacle when he wanted to coach here
For say Zach Taylor there is a Kliff Kingsbury - -of course the front office has helped in Cincy while in AZ - that was almost a Charger like cluster. So the organization matters. But for sure, a Kyle Shanahan type would be awesome but a few things about Kyle Shanahan compared to say Ben Johnson - Shanahan was an OC for 8 years before he got the gig with the Niners. Sure, he worked for his Dad part of the time but also was OC with the Browns (and we know what a crap show that was - but a great learning experience probably) as well as the Falcons
Ben Johnson - barely two years as an OC
Bobby Slowik - one year
Mike McDonalds Ravens DC - 8 years coaching total, one year as DC for Michigan and now one year for DC in Baltimore
Where is that Kyle Shanahan that has a crap load of experience and truly the only name that comes to mind is Eric Public (or Sleeping with) Bieniemy |__ __ | - the touchdown signal he used to do. Unless you hire Todd Monken type
-
👍 1
- Top
- Bottom
Leave a comment:
-
-
Originally posted by Bolt4Knob View Post
I would take Mike Vrabel or Todd Bowles at this point over guys like McCoy, Lynn, Kingsbury, McDaniels, Hackett, Nagy
I am not against an Offensive minded HC - I wanted Payton last year and want Harbaugh this year. But again, I am not limiting to one side of the ball
-
👍 1
- Top
- Bottom
Leave a comment:
-
Leave a comment: